Monday, September 5, 2011

Two more from Lord Byron

"I remember a methodist preacher who on perceiving a profane grin on the faces of part of his congregation exclaimed 'no hopes for them as laughs'"

"His answer was, that his style was a system, or upon system, or some such cant; and when a man talks of system, his case is hopeless."

Lord Byron, Selected Letters and Journals

Lord Byron - taste and its drawback

"If you enter his [the poet Rogers] house--his drawing room--his library--you of yourself say, this is not the dwelling of a common mind.  There is not a gem, a coin, a book thrown aside on his chimney piece, his sofa, his table, that does not bespeak of an almost fastidious elegance in the possessor.  But this very delicacy must be the misery of his existence.  Oh the jarrings his disposition must have encountered through life!"

Lord Byron; Selected Letters and Journals

The percent of GNP measure

Nearly all the measures of U.S. Government spending that you see are presented as a percentage of GNP.  That this measure is so commonplace is rather curious, because from a spending side it makes no sense.  The rationale for government spending is need, so why would spending track GNP?

Government is of course different from business, but in the business world if you are projecting growth in a budget or plan your expense target will almost always be at a lower percentage.  That is you expect your expenditures to go up but at a slower pace than revenues.  Government expenditures should follow a similar path, there being no reason why military, social security, the judicial system, etc. costs should go up at the same rate as GNP.

More directly, you would think that as a nation became wealthier the safety net would become proportionally smaller.  If say you had a decade where real income doubled you would still have people who would need assistance, but presumably you’d have many more that would move to a state of self-sufficiency. 

This may seem to be of no importance, but I don’t think it is.  The measures used tend to both reflect and shape thinking.  Until the current recession, we had a rather extraordinary economic run.  It seems reasonable to ask whether the standard view of looking at expenditures as a percent of GNP contributed to making commitments which are unsustainable when growth slowed significantly.  Measure expenditures on a percent of GNP basis concedes that spending is based on affordability rather than need.  That’s a big concession.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

The Economy - the question of what to do

This morning I went to the Star & Tribune to find out how the Gopher football team did against USC.  Reading sports columnist Joe Souhan I naturally got political opinion: “Congress might want to take a few notes about quickly making good decisions.”  Behold the idiotic notion that it is only politics that keeps good things from happening right away.

The nub of course is “good decisions.”  What eludes Souhan is that what constitutes a good decision my not be obvious or shared by everyone; case in point, stimulus spending to drag an economy out of a recession.  If you are roughly my age, you’ve been fully drilled in this view, but as noted elsewhere on this blog, Keynesianism is premised on too much saving while our current predicament is too much debt. 

Then there is the question of whether Keynes’ solution really was the miracle cure of the last depression.  Arthur Herman’s piece in The Weekly Standard makes you wonder.  Herman takes a look at World War II—“the ultimate stimulus”—and points out how the economic data doesn’t quite support the deficit spending myth.  Economist Robert Barro states that “the data show that output expanded during World War Two by less than the increase in military purchases.”  If you read the piece you’re struck not by how government spending lifted the economy out of depression but rather how the story follows Bastiat’s broken windows fallacy, that you can grow an economy by breaking things because people will be employing in fixing them.

What is particularly illuminating is the post war boom and the reduction in government spending that went with it.  By Keynesian logic this should have led to contraction not expansion.
“This postwar boom has always posed a problem for Keynesians like Krugman. As government spending plummeted with the coming of peace— military spending alone collapsed from 37.5 percent of GDP in 1945 to just 5.5 percent in 1947—many predicted that, without this prop and with the new burden of millions of returning veterans looking for work, the economy would sink once more into the abyss. Paul Samuelson, later the dean of American Keynesian economists, wrote that unless the government did something drastic, “there would be ushered in the greatest period of unemployment and industrial dislocation which any economy has ever faced.”
Instead, after a brief hiccup in 1946, the economy rebounded, growing from $231 billion GDP in 1947—roughly what it was in 1945—to $258 billion in 1948, and from there to $285 billion in 1950. Unemployment, despite the dire predictions, increased only to 3.9 percent between 1945 and 1947, in spite of the fact that some 10 million new workers came into the civilian labor market”
Herman argues that what caused the boom was business investment, the very same thing that went in decline as America prepared for and went into war.  “Instead, the biggest trigger to growth turns out to have been a sharp rise in private capital investment, which the New Deal had slowed—one reason the Great Depression lingered as long as it did, Higgs argues—and the war had all but halted. That investment jumped from $10.6 billion in 1945 to $46 billion in 1948, as plants expanded and retooled for the production of civilian goods. Even though the overall personal savings rate fell, the private investment rate soared from 5 percent to almost 18 percent, with the biggest leap coming in 1946—a leap that would be reflected in GNP numbers only two years later. Meanwhile, business savings almost doubled in the same period, from $15.1 billion to $28 billion—providing a sure way to finance expansion and hiring.”


Friday, September 2, 2011

Free speech

"...why in fact do we cherish the right to speak freely?  Because we have become a people with a variety of opinions about all sorts of matters and we do not see why we should not utter them.  We know there are limits to this right, but we know also that these limits have nothing whatever to do with 'truth' and 'error', but only with peace and tranquility.  The proper rationale of free speech, and the limits commonly imposed upon it by liberal-democratic governments, is not the belief that every utterance is a bona fide participation in a search for some one 'truth', but the belief that politics are not concerned with this sort of 'truth' at all.  They are concerned with the cultivation of what from time to time are accepted as the peacable decencies of conduct among men who do not suffer from the Purtian-Jacobin illusion that in practical affairs there is an attainable condition of things called 'truth' or 'perfection.'"

Michael Oakeshott, Religion, Politics, and the Moral Life, The Customer is Never Wrong , page 116
Review of Walter Lippman's The Public Philosophy

Another green investment fails

I picked up and read The Death of Conservatism yesterday which argues that movement conservatism expired at the hands of Barack Obama, “a leader of rare political skills.” I also read yesterday that solar panel maker Solyndra is declaring bankruptcy and closing its doors.  According to the report at Bloomberg “the company had borrowed $527 million of the $535 million covered by the Energy Departments loan guarantees.  Solyndra was part of the Obama administrations efforts to create green jobs.

What caught my eye in the story was this:

“The Energy Department’s portfolio of dozens of other government-backed investments ‘continues to perform well and is on pace to create thousands of jobs’.”

The claim that these investments are actually on pace is dubious, as other noted stories have pointed out, but the real question is what is the government doing talking about its investment portfolio?  The typical justification for government is need, but if there is one thing you would think isn’t in short supply in America it is capital and people willing to pursue riches (at least prior to the Obama administration).

It is also my understanding that government officials like the president have to put their investments into a blind trust so as to avoid conflicts of interest.  Are we then to assume that a government portfolio is conflict free?  I doubt it.  Those obviously outmoded ideas of conservatism--like the idea that government isn't very good at picking economic winners--are looking pretty good these days

Addendum:  Rich Lowry on Solyndra http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/276119/obama-s-enron-rich-lowry

Thursday, September 1, 2011

Jeff Miron on capitalism and income distribution

“The 2nd myth is that capitalism generates an unfair distribution of income. What true capitalism does is rewards people who are productive, people who work a lot of hours, people who have a lot of talent, people who come up with good ideas, they get big rewards.  People who don’t do those things get less.” http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2011/08/jeff-miron-on-capitalism.html

So says Harvard economics professor Jeff Miron in his three myths of capitalism.  Without a great deal of elaboration and qualification this statement is unlikely to convince anyone not already convinced.  Left alone it probably hurts the case of capitalism just like any other weak argument.

First, if you look at businesses it isn’t clear that profitability is aligned with the values of a society, to the extent we can ascribe values to a society.  For instance gaming and pornography are or have been lucrative businesses.  The social stigma attached to both probably helps their profitability in that it keeps out competition. 

In investment services it isn’t clear that the benefit of making the markets more efficient by closing small price discrepancies is worth the enormous profits and divergence of skilled manpower that has gone into this field.  Moreover, the people who could most critically benefit from having a skilled financial advisor can’t afford it, whereas those who already have a great deal of money have access to the best advice thereby accentuating differences in wealth.

For individuals the statement is even more dubious.  Consider sports where statistics provide at least something approaching objective measures of performance. Prof. Miron will have a tough time convincing White Sox fans that capitalism is in tune with performance when Adam Dunn in the first year of a four year contract that will pay him $56 million is on pace to have the lowest batting average of anyone who ever had enough at bats to qualify for the batting title (he’s hitting .163 with 157 strikeouts out of 368 at bats). 

In truth, as only who works outside of academia will notice, there is considerable luck involved in how much money you make.  How the company performs, how your area is perceived within the firm, how well your boss does and how well he or she supports you are at least as important as hard work and talent.  You can be an exceptional employee and if you are on the wrong side of an acquisition you’re likely to find yourself out of a job.

I would assume Mr. Miron would accept most of these objections, so what is he saying?  I believe his point should be understood by thinking of a normal distribution or the bell curve, that is with the bulk of the population in the middle and smaller numbers at the extremes.  Capitalism distributes income in something like a normal distribution when you look at businesses and individuals.  The majority will earn about what they are worth, with lesser numbers being either lucky or unlucky all the way to the extremes.  Attempts to equalize income aren't fair since they deny these differences.

But it is important not to oversell capitalism as I believe Prof. Miron does in this clip.  The “cure” for whatever unfairness exists in the distribution of income may well be worse than the disease.  And it should be kept in mind that the benefits of capitalism are largely derivative, that the chief argument for capitalism is that it is the only system consistent with a truly free people.  If Krushchev’s boast that communism would bury the West economically had come to pass it wouldn’t make it a better political system than ours.  What needs to be made more consistently is not an economic argument for capitalism but an argument for it that doesn’t rely on its material benefits.  And one that recognizes that life is indeed unfair.