Ever wonder why the left is always falling head over heels for their nominee. Or how Tom Friedman can have a, no masterpiece was written by committee, attitude towards American democracy. In 2008 Barack Obama, a man whose resume could fit on a credit card, was FDR and JFK wrapped into one glittering package. His election would halt the rise in the oceans and redeem the American experience. The too easy answer is that this is just power worship. The allure of getting to tell other people what to do. But a less cynical explanation is hiding in plain sight. Hiding in fourteenth century Florence to be exact.
At that time the elites competed with each other by building cathedrals rather than big governments and the grandees of Florence were a bit over-extended. The crossing space of the cathedral--a little over 144 feet--exceeded the technological know-how for building free standing domes. A hundred years after construction had begun, when the dome could no longer be put off, a competition is held to find a solution. Brunelleschi wins and his solution for a free standing dome is still an engineering marvel.
Here in the Western democracies we are now in the position of holding semi-regular competitions called elections to find the person who can put 'a roof' over the vast government that we've created as monuments to our humanity, our capacity to care. And it isn't at all surprising that progressives, far more invested in the government project, are far more invested in finding an 'architect or engineer' to complete the project. Thus, the extravagant celebration and hopes attached to the election of Barack Obama and before him Bill Clinton.
Nor is it surprising that our political Brunelleschies are looked for in the ranks of the relative unknowns. If the known, experienced politician had the solution wouldn't we have seen it by now? The one thing we can deduce from our familiarity with establishment politicians with all of their government experience is that they don't have the answer.
The analogy also suggests why the conservative argument that ambitious government programs have failed and can't work seem to persuade only other conservatives. Even if the progressive can be persuaded of failure he will tack on a 'not yet' qualifier. Here it has to be admitted, the conservative is working against American optimism. Hayek's knowledge problem is just a big data application from being resolved. Like the Florence Cathedral the pursuit of the outsized goal doesn't require a ready solution as one is sure to turn up if we just keep the faith.
It was Patrick Moynihan who observed that "somehow liberals have been unable to acquire from a lifetime of experience what conservatives seem to be endowed with at birth: namely, a healthy skepticism of the powers of government to do good." The remark is truer today than when he made it as is the gap between our commitments and the revenue to pay for them. And so the outsized hopes pinned on political candidates continue and the more acute our problems become, the wilder and more frantic our search for a miracle worker.
"Schopenhauer tells us of a colony of porcupines wont to huddle together...able neither to tolerate nor to do without one another, until they discovered that when they stood at a certain distance..they could delight in one another's individuality and enjoy one another's company. Unknown to themselves they'd invented civil association"
Thursday, December 17, 2015
Tuesday, December 15, 2015
The Long Game of Candidate Cruz and the Untameable Senator
@UWedge: "If you know you're going to lose then fighting is just theatre."
Have you noticed? A huge gap has opened up in the Republican nomination race. No, not Trump and the rest of the field in national polls. The gap between candidate and Senator Ted Cruz.
In the Republican field Cruz has been last and least in
offering up any criticism of Donald Trump. As has been widely noted he’s
playing a long game which recognizes that he is the second choice for Trump
supporters. So the strategy is obvious, be patient, let the others take on
Trump and bring him down, and then be there for his supporters on the rebound.
What I haven’t seen is anyone pointing to the dilemma
implicit in this strategy. Cruz the presidential candidate opens up a
different, and highly unflattering, perspective on Cruz the Senator. Put
simply, Cruz the candidate can’t be squared with Cruz the Senator and the
reason for candidate Cruz is Senator Cruz.
Cruz is popular with conservatives because he gave them in
the Senate what they longed for. Not victories—he really doesn’t have any—but risk
taking. As Senator he embodies what the base wants. The cause! The cause! and
damn the consequences! That is his motto. He is the nothing ventured, nothing
gained rebuke to Mitch McConnell who has a habit of infuriating conservatives
with his McClellan like, maybe after the next election when we’re stronger,
approach to politics.
The ever prudent, bide your time Cruz is now asking us to
question just what Senator Cruz was up to. It doesn’t look like the exuberance
of the conviction politician so much as advertisements for Ted Cruz. It raises
the question who was less sincere, Marlon Brando playing Johnny Strabler in The
Wild One, or Ted Cruz playing Ted Cruz. I had doubts about Cruz as president
before, I have bigger doubts now.
Labels:
Politics,
Republican nomination 2016,
tea party,
Ted Cruz
Friday, December 11, 2015
Why The Politics of the Impossible? OK, I'll Bite
“People
routinely say with apparent certainty serious things that are if not patently
false at least highly uncertain. And there is no debate, no confrontation of
facts or analysis. The things people say
are not meant to be measured on the scale of truth. They are only the signs by
which one indicates which team one belongs to, like the ‘identification friend-or-foe’
signals that warplanes emit.”
-Herbert Stein, 1989
At The Federalist today [link at the bottom], Mark Hemingway notes that
progressives are now calling for the confiscation of guns in America and have
established the goal of eliminating gun violence and he asks why, given that
neither the tactic nor goal has any real chance of being realized? Now as The
Heminator isn’t your typical Oregonian to be found naked in a field, I take
it his question is one of them rhetoricals, but why let that stop me from
chiming in with an answer?
I would start by pointing to Kenneth Minogue’s The
Servile Mind: How Democracy Erodes the Moral Life. Minogue’s thesis is that
traditional morality is gradually being replaced by the “political-moral.”
Instead of moral concerns and markers like honesty, trustworthiness, humility,
duty to be moral is now associated with voting for the right politicians and
supporting—publicly of course—the right causes. Participate in an ad for ending
gun violence and you can cheat on your spouse, steal water for you lawn, and
treat the help shabbily.
Next, I would point to Walker Percy’s Lost in the Cosmos
which suggests by way of example that the things we typically designate as
tragedies have a positive aspect. Yes, the storm that rips through your town
destroying everything that’s in its path is bad and a tragedy, but it also
makes life exciting and provides a break from the every-day tedium of our
lives. The Percy Formula—copyright @LMandrakeJr, LTD—stipulates the more
impossible the cause the greater its value. Pick a finite goal like stopping
the XYX Development or building a park in the East River Area and soon you’ll
be back in the existential emptiness of not having a cause. That the cause is eternal is a feature, not a bug.
Finally, I would argue that what Hemingway has noted is
symptomatic of what Michael Oakeshott (the philosopher, not the welder) defined
as rationalism in politics. Oakeshott maintained that our current politics were
thoroughly rationalist and went on to describe some of its characteristics:
“He [the Rationalist] is the enemy
of authority, of prejudice, of the merely traditional, customary, or habitual…He
is optimistic because the Rationalist never doubts the power of his ‘reason’ to
determine the worth of a thing, the truth of an opinion, or the propriety of an
action.
He does not recognize change unless
it is self-consciously induced change.
The politics it inspires may be
called the politics of the felt need; for the Rationalist, politics are always
charged with the feeling of the moment.
And the ‘rational’ solution of any
problem is, in its nature, the perfect solution. There is no in his scheme for
a ‘best in the circumstances’, only a place for ‘the best’; because the
function of reason is precisely to surmount circumstances.”
Later, in a different essay in the same collection Oakeshott
memorably sketches his alternative view of politics:
“In political activity, then, men
sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbor for shelter nor
floor for anchorage, neither starting place nor appointed destination. The
enterprise is to keep afloat on an even keel; the sea is both friend and enemy;
and the seamanship consists in using the resources of a traditional manner of
behavior in order to make a friend of every hostile occasion.”
It is the politics of intimations rather than certainty, of
tacking rather than proceeding “as the crow flies”, of incremental rather than ‘comprehensive’
reform. Yes, please!
Stop Trying to ‘End Gun Violence’. It’s Not Going to Happen,
Mark Hemingway http://thefederalist.com/2015/12/11/stop-trying-to-end-gun-violence-its-not-going-to-happen/
Labels:
Conservatism,
Gun Control,
Mark Hemingway,
Political philosophy,
Politics,
Progressivism,
The Federalist
Thursday, December 10, 2015
Conservative Suspicions
[The conservative] “will be suspicious of proposals for
change in excess of what the situation calls for, of rulers, who demand
extra-ordinary powers in order to make great changes and whose utterances are
tied to generalities like ‘the public good’ or ‘social justice’, and of saviors
of society who buckle on armor and seek dragons to slay.”
- Michael Oakeshott, Rationalism in Politics
The Gun Control Talk Leads to Gun Sales Argument
For a while there was a cultural/political ritual that went
like this: a public museum would decide to have an exhibition on something like
the history of porn or blasphemy in the arts, a group would object, and the
response would be a) censorship! and b) don’t you realize you idiot that you’re
only drawing more attention to the art you object to? In short, the gist of the
counter-argument was that whatever outrage we can conjure up should be accepted
in silence.
The same argument is now being trotted out in support of the
second amendment in reaction to calls for stricter gun control. The Progressive
argument for gun control is leading to increased NRA membership and gun sales.
As in the earlier battle of the arts, I don’t find this line of argument
particularly convincing.
In the first place, the criteria of practicality is
misplaced. On a simple cost-benefit analysis this blog, like most things I do,
is a huge waste of time. We all, well most of us, know that in arguing with
friends we aren’t going to change anyone’s mind and we may very well make them
angry. We do it anyway, because in truth most of us have opinions and we so no
reason why we shouldn’t express them.
But if we accept practicality as THE criteria the argument
still mostly falls apart on the dimension of time. We start running and get all
sore and miserable so that we’ll get in shape and feel better on some future
day. In business, first are the cash outflows, later—we hope—the cash inflows.
We object to Piss Christ in order to gather followers with an eye to the next
exhibition. Jonah Goldberg put the matter rather well in response to the same
argument at the start of the Iraq War, part 2:
“If my backyard is festooned with hornet nests, I will
likely be safer from a sting on any given day if I do nothing than I will be on
the day or days I begin destroying them. Since when is any large, important,
task required to show positive results at every stage?”
That, I say, is a good point.
Mind you, none of the above should be taken as
taking the side of gun control or still less for gun confiscation. To my mind
the second amendment defenders have the better of the argument. But I have an
impractical need to object to an argument I find mostly irrelevant.
Labels:
2nd Amendment,
Censorship,
Conservatism,
Gun Control,
Political Debates,
Politics
Wednesday, December 9, 2015
Chicago; Yes, But Then What?
As a kid I remember my uncle, who worked at O’Hare telling me that if your precinct didn’t go for the Mayor your streets would be the last to get plowed when it snowed. When my brother moved to Chicago after finishing school he relayed his election strategy: "I vote against all the incumbents; the new guys will be corrupt too but they won’t be as good at it." Shortly before the runoff election for mayor, I answered a phone poll:
Q: On a scale of 1 – 10, ten being the highest, how likely are you to vote for Rahm?
Me: 10
Q: On a scale of 1 – 10 how would you rate Rahm’s job performance?
Me: 1
The question in Chicago isn't what should become of Rahm Emanuel but at this point, what difference does it make. As Jonah Goldberg pointed out today, Chicago is a one party city. How one party? In the 2012 Presidential election, Barack Obama got 74% of the vote in Cook County. Ah, you say Obama is from Chicago, of course he did well. In 2004 John Kerry did only slightly worse picking up 70% of the vote. And if anything these results understate things. Of the city's 50 alderman, 49 are Democrats. Forty-nine flippin' Dems out of a total of fifty!
I'm more than fine with investigating the police department, I'd be happy to see Rahm go (voting for him was, shall we say, painful), but what then? The normal recourse here is to democracy, but I think it is fair to say that democracy has failed in Chicago. The city is for all intents and purposes broke, it's citizens are leaving, Rahm's opponent in the last election ran to his left. Chicago in the worst way needs a vibrant conservative oriented opposition party, but getting one....? To that, well..."we all want to see the plan."
Me: 10
Q: On a scale of 1 – 10 how would you rate Rahm’s job performance?
Me: 1
The question in Chicago isn't what should become of Rahm Emanuel but at this point, what difference does it make. As Jonah Goldberg pointed out today, Chicago is a one party city. How one party? In the 2012 Presidential election, Barack Obama got 74% of the vote in Cook County. Ah, you say Obama is from Chicago, of course he did well. In 2004 John Kerry did only slightly worse picking up 70% of the vote. And if anything these results understate things. Of the city's 50 alderman, 49 are Democrats. Forty-nine flippin' Dems out of a total of fifty!
I'm more than fine with investigating the police department, I'd be happy to see Rahm go (voting for him was, shall we say, painful), but what then? The normal recourse here is to democracy, but I think it is fair to say that democracy has failed in Chicago. The city is for all intents and purposes broke, it's citizens are leaving, Rahm's opponent in the last election ran to his left. Chicago in the worst way needs a vibrant conservative oriented opposition party, but getting one....? To that, well..."we all want to see the plan."
Labels:
Chicago conservatism,
Chicago politics,
Politics,
Rahm Emanuel resignation,
Republican Party-Chicago
On Refugee-Immigrant Issue, It's the Screening
In the discussion of Muslim immigration and accepting
refugees there has been a great deal of focus on secondary issues and little
attention on the main one. If citizens were confident that the government could
distinguish between Muslims that were coming here to embrace America and
Muslims who remain committed to sharia law and are either already radicalized
or pre-disposed to radicalism we wouldn’t be having this debate.
At National Review today Andrew McCarthy argues that the “they’ll
lie” critique of the (rather silly in my view) Trump proposal is “meritless”.
He points out that the burden of proof is on the immigrant and that it is a felony punishable by five years’
imprisonment to lie on government forms or to government agents conducting a
legitimate investigation.” But of course it is the state that has the burden of
proof in criminal cases to prove guilt, and yet somehow, someway we regularly
read stories about people being released from prison because it later turns out
they were innocent. The reticence of some/many to accept Syrian refugees in
large numbers has been described as bigotry and un-American and is loudly
supported by the President. In which direction do you think government
officials will be inclined to tilt the scales in evaluating applications?
Today on Twitter
Stephen Hayes of the Weekly Standard posted that the “terrorist sent 109
encrypted messages to overseas jihadist morning of Garland attack.” The FBI
failed to pick up on this. Still think doubts about immigrant vetting are
groundless?
In the movie
Casino, the mobsters from Kansas City are in court and during a break they get
into a discussion of what to do about potential witnesses:
Vinny Forlano: He
won't talk. Stone is a good kid. Stand-up guy, just like his old man. That's
the way I see it.
Vincent Borelli: I agree. He's solid. A fuckin' Marine.
Capelli: He's okay. He always was. Remo, what do you think?
Remo Gaggi: Look... why take a
chance? At least, that's the way I feel about it.
Sadly, the government has given us plenty of reason to feel like Remo Gaggi. Given the stakes we’re not inclined to be Flounder and be told at a not too distant date by some government Otter that “you fucked up….you trusted us.” The issue is the screening, stupid.
http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/428244/its-impractical-because-theyll-lie-objection-trumps-proposal-meritless-andrew-c
Labels:
2016 election,
immigration,
Politics,
Syrian refugees,
tea party,
Trump
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)